Where to Eat in Highland, Indiana: 6 Restaurants Downtown and on Indianapolis Boulevard

by Sash Joveski

Highland's restaurants mostly sit in two places: downtown around Highway Avenue, Jewett Avenue and Condit Street, and along Indianapolis Boulevard (US 41). Downtown, Langel's Pizza has the pizza and the big sports bar, Les Cafe Pancake House handles breakfast from 6 a.m., Dan's Pierogies does Polish food and Fuzzyline Brewing Co. pairs its beer with sourdough pizzas. On the boulevard, Miner-Dunn Real Hamburgers has served burgers since 1932, and Theo's Steaks & Seafood is the pick for a sit-down steak and seafood dinner.

Realest graphic titled Where to Eat in Highland, Indiana, listing Langel's Pizza, Les Cafe Pancake House, Dan's Pierogies, Fuzzyline Brewing Co., Miner-Dunn Real Hamburgers and Theo's Steaks and Seafood with their street addresses

We're based in Crown Point and help buyers and sellers across Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland, including Highland. This guide sticks to what each restaurant says about itself, plus local reporting where we found it. Hours change, so check each restaurant's own site or call before you go.

Downtown Highland

1. Langel's Pizza, 2833 Highway Ave

Langel's has been part of downtown Highland since 1979, according to its menu, and runs alongside Rodney's Sports Bar, which the restaurant says has 40 HD TVs. There's a family dining area, an outdoor cafe that is heated and enclosed in winter, two banquet rooms and off-site catering. The menu covers hand-tossed, thin and double-crust pizza plus homemade Italian beef, and ABC7's Localish stopped in to feature the Big Dill pizza. Langel's Pizza website

2. Les Cafe Pancake House, 2708 Highway Ave

Les Cafe is the early option on this list. Its site lists hours of 6 a.m. to 4 p.m. every day, with pancakes, omelets, skillets, sandwiches and coffee on a breakfast and lunch menu. You'll also see it listed as Les Brothers Cafe Pancake House in the town's downtown directory. Les Cafe Pancake House website

3. Dan's Pierogies, 2945 Jewett Ave

Dan's Pierogies has served Polish food since 1998 and opened its downtown Highland shop at 2945 Jewett Ave in 2015, according to its website. The menu lists more than a dozen pierogi flavors, sold cooked one at a time or frozen by the dozen, plus stuffed cabbage, cabbage and noodles, blintzes and a different special each day it's open, with a fish fry on Fridays. Take-home sausage, kiszka and soup by the quart are on the menu too. It keeps daytime hours, Tuesday through Saturday. Dan's Pierogies menu

4. Fuzzyline Brewing Co., 2712 Condit St

Fuzzyline is a sour-focused brewery founded by Al Robertson and Chef Bob McLellan that also pours IPAs, stouts and lagers. The kitchen side is a big part of the draw: the menu runs from bao buns and crispy Brussels sprouts to double smash burgers and house-made sourdough pizzas, and The Times of Northwest Indiana featured McLellan's sourdough pizzas in December 2024. The brewery says its taproom welcomes all ages, the patio is dog-friendly, and the private Matador Room holds up to 25 guests. Fuzzyline menu

Indianapolis Boulevard

5. Miner-Dunn Real Hamburgers, 8940 Indianapolis Blvd

Miner-Dunn dates to May 19, 1932, when Harold Miner and Ralph Dunn opened a six-stool restaurant on Calumet Avenue in Hammond, according to the restaurant's history page. Today it operates from Indianapolis Boulevard in Highland. The menu centers on burgers, hand-spun shakes and malts, hand-cut fries, homemade soups and pies, and the orange sherbet the restaurant calls famous. Miner-Dunn history

6. Theo's Steaks & Seafood, 9144 Indianapolis Blvd

Theo's describes itself as fine dining, and its dinner menu lists USDA Prime steaks, wild-caught seafood that can be prepared several ways, chops and pasta, along with saganaki flamed tableside. It serves lunch and dinner and also offers banquets and catering. Theo's dinner menu

Schematic graphic, not to scale, grouping Langel's Pizza, Les Cafe Pancake House, Dan's Pierogies and Fuzzyline Brewing Co. in downtown Highland around Highway Avenue, Jewett Avenue and Condit Street, and Miner-Dunn Real Hamburgers and Theo's Steaks and Seafood on Indianapolis Boulevard
Schematic only, not to scale. Addresses come from each restaurant's own website.

Planning a meal in Highland

The four downtown spots sit within a few blocks of each other, so it's easy to park once for breakfast at Les Cafe or a late lunch at Dan's and walk around. Miner-Dunn and Theo's are a short drive away on Indianapolis Boulevard. Dan's closes at 6 p.m. and is closed Sundays and Mondays, and Fuzzyline is closed Mondays, so a quick look at each site before you head out saves a wasted trip. The town's Explore Downtown Highland page lists more cafes, sweets and shops nearby.

Something new is also on the way. The Times reported on November 16, 2026 that Lucy's Barbecue plans to open in the former Town Club space, which closed after 79 years. It isn't open yet, so watch for an opening date.

Thinking about living in Highland?

If downtown Highland feels like your speed, our guide to living in Highland covers the town itself, and you can browse Highland homes on RealEstateUSA. Love Thy Neighbor is how we try to show up in every town we serve, and the local restaurants are a big part of what makes a place feel like home.

Questions about buying or selling in Highland or anywhere in Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland? Call Sash at (219) 808-1520.

Frequently asked questions

Where are most restaurants in Highland, Indiana?

Many of Highland's local restaurants are downtown around Highway Avenue, Jewett Avenue and Condit Street, with another group along Indianapolis Boulevard (US 41). Langel's Pizza, Les Cafe Pancake House, Dan's Pierogies and Fuzzyline Brewing Co. are downtown, and Miner-Dunn Real Hamburgers and Theo's Steaks & Seafood are on Indianapolis Boulevard.

Where can I get breakfast in Highland?

Les Cafe Pancake House at 2708 Highway Ave serves breakfast and lunch from 6 a.m. to 4 p.m. daily, according to its website.

Where can I find Polish food in Highland?

Dan's Pierogies has served Polish food since 1998 and has been at 2945 Jewett Ave since 2015, with pierogies cooked to order or frozen by the dozen, stuffed cabbage and daily specials. It is open Tuesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 6 p.m., per its website.

How long has Miner-Dunn been around?

Miner-Dunn opened on May 19, 1932, in Hammond, according to the restaurant's history page. It now operates at 8940 Indianapolis Blvd in Highland.

Is there a family-friendly brewery in Highland?

Fuzzyline Brewing Co. at 2712 Condit St says its taproom welcomes all ages and its patio is dog-friendly. It serves a full food menu, including sourdough pizzas and smash burgers.

Sources checked November 17, 2026: each restaurant's own website, the Town of Highland's Explore Downtown Highland page, and The Times of Northwest Indiana.

Andrea Galvez

Realest.com

GET IN TOUCH

Name
Phone*
Message